A goal from Giacomo Vrioni in the 30th minute was enough for the New England Revolution to take down the Red Bulls for the first time since 2021.
Held scoreless for the second time in two matches, the Red Bulls only managed two shots on target.
Midfielder Ibrahim Kasule made his first-team debut when he was subbed in in the 64th minute.
New York will now travel to Philadelphia to take on the Union on Sunday at Subaru Park at 7:30pm EST.
