During the 2017 season Koffi started 21 games for the Cavaliers, earning a First Team All-ACC Selection while contributing three goals and four assists, which was tied for the team lead. At the end of the season Koffi was ranked ninth in TopDrawerSoccer.com’s National College Soccer Player Rankings. In all, he made 57 appearances for UVA over three seasons, with six goals and seven assists.
New York Red Bulls sign Jean-Cristophe Koffi to an MLS contract effective January 1, 2019 as a Homegrown. Koffi joined New York Red Bulls II (USL) for the remainder of the 2018 season.