Lee Nguyen's penalty had put New England in front in the ninth minute, but the Red Bulls woke up and dominated play after that, finally equalizing on Bradley Wright-Phillips' backheel into an empty net in the 47th minute. Daniel Royer's tap-in of a Kemar Lawrence square pass in the 74th minute proved to be the game-winner.
- 9' – NE – Lee Nguyen (PK) Watch
- 47' – NY – Bradley Wright-Phillips Watch
- 74' – NY – Daniel Royer Watch